I'm Trapped in a Cuckolding Fantasy About My Girlfriend and Her Ex
Share
"Jealous. Disgusted. And something else. Something I couldn't control. I started fantasizing about things I didn't want to be fantasizing about."
Blake
The Story: As Told by Blake
It happened on a lazy weekend.
My girlfriend reminded me to vacuum. The carpet hadn't been cleaned in a while. I decided to be thorough about it.
Looking back, that was my biggest regret.
I found a silicone dildo while sorting through the clutter. Very realistic. And engraved clearly at its base: a name. Not mine. I recognized it, the name of an ex she'd mentioned once.
I should have confronted her immediately. Instead, I stood there staring at it for a long time.
Before sex one night, I couldn't hold it in anymore and brought it up. She was mortified. Said it was a dumb impulse purchase from that past relationship, forgotten about after the breakup. She apologized seriously and said she'd throw it away immediately.
That should have been the end of it.
But I used it during sex. Her reaction gave me a kind of excitement I'd never felt before. Shame and arousal, disgusting and addictive in the same breath.
She apologized again afterward.
I love her. Of that I'm certain.
But I've been questioning myself ever since. Am I enjoying being compared? Is this some deep self-loathing? Do I need this kind of thing to punish myself? Am I so insecure at my core that this is how it surfaces?
I don't know.
The Reality Check: Shame and Kink Can Coexist
Blake stumbled into a cuckolding response.
Cuckolding is a specific arousal. It comes from imagining, or experiencing, a partner engaging sexually with someone else. It's one of the more common kink responses, deeply tied to the psychology of threat and desire colliding.
Why Do People Enjoy It?
The reasons vary. For some, jealousy and humiliation are all part of the mix. Watching or imagining a partner with someone else triggers a possessive charge that reframes desire entirely. For others, cuckolding is a way to break out of monotony, finding that the added dimension deepens their connection.
There's even a word for it: compersion.
Sexologists often consider cuckolding a branch of BDSM territory. The submission and loss of control involved can overlap with masochistic dynamics.
So What Now?
You've been caught between the shame of wanting it and the fear of losing it. Neither you nor your girlfriend has ever talked about this as a kink. Only as a strange thing that happened.
In that kind of awkward framing, there's no room to make a real decision.
Here's what BADISM suggests:
- Slow down on the self-judgment.Punishing yourself mentally will only make things worse. Cuckolding responses don't make you broken. If anything, they're far more common than most people admit. Seeking out a sex-positive therapist and grounding yourself in real research can help you move out of the shadow of that day.
- Have a different conversation.Not about the dildo, not about the ex's name, and not about who needs to apologize. Talk honestly about what happened and how you both feel about it now.
- Check in on her.Your girlfriend has apologized twice. Her comfort and willingness matter. If she's reluctant, troubled, or resistant, respect that boundary. The world is full of play that can excite both of you.
Beyond the Default Script
Society hands us a fixed script for romantic relationships. Breaking it, even in fantasy, can feel like evidence that something has gone wrong.
But relationships don't come in one shape. What matters is that both people understand what they're stepping into, and that pleasure is built on informed consent.
That's true whether you're exploring cuckolding or any other dynamic.
Have a question or a story to share? Send your submissions to confess@badism.net. We select featured stories for our blog regularly. If your story is published, you'll receive a special brand gift.